Structuring a Joint Development Agreement (JDA): Co-Creating IP with a Strategic Partner

Takeaway: A Joint Development Agreement is a high-stakes collaboration that requires a meticulously crafted IP clause to determine ownership of newly created inventions, ensuring your startup retains the rights it needs to build its core business.

A strategic partnership with a large corporation can be a company-making event for a startup. Often, this partnership goes beyond a simple customer relationship and evolves into a formal Joint Development Agreement (JDA). A JDA is a contract where your startup and a corporate partner agree to collaborate on a joint R&D project to create a new technology or product together.

While a JDA can provide invaluable resources and market validation, it is also one of the most legally complex agreements you will ever negotiate. At its heart is a single, critical question: who owns the intellectual property that you create together? The answer to this question, which is defined in the JDA's IP clause, will have profound consequences for the future of your company.

The Core IP Negotiation

The negotiation over the IP clause in a JDA is a complex dance. The goal is to create a "win-win" structure that allows both parties to achieve their strategic objectives. The negotiation will focus on three categories of IP:

1. Background IP: This is the intellectual property that each party brings into the collaboration. The JDA must clearly state that each party retains full ownership of its own Background IP.
2. Foreground IP Created Solely by One Party: The agreement should be clear that if your employees, working on their own, create a new invention during the project, your company owns that invention. Likewise, if the partner's employees create an invention, they own it.
3. Jointly Created Foreground IP: This is the most complex category. This is the new IP that is created through the true, collaborative effort of both teams working together. The default rule is that this IP is "jointly owned."

The Dangers of "Joint Ownership"

While "joint ownership" sounds fair and simple, it is a legal and commercial nightmare. Under U.S. patent law, each co-owner of a patent can practice the invention without any duty to account to the other owner. This means your partner could potentially license the jointly owned IP to your direct competitor, and you would have no say in the matter.

For this reason, a well-drafted JDA will almost never rely on the default rule of joint ownership. Instead, it will create a more sophisticated structure.

A Better Solution: "Field of Use" Licensing

A common and more effective solution is to assign ownership based on the "field of use."

• The Structure: The JDA will assign full ownership of all jointly created IP to one party (often the startup, which is more focused on building an IP portfolio).
• The License-Back: The owning party then grants the other party a broad, perpetual license to use that IP, but only within their specific, pre-defined field of use.
  • Example: Your startup is collaborating with a large automotive company. Your startup might own the resulting patents but grant the auto company an exclusive license to use the technology only for automotive applications. Your startup would then retain the rights to use that same technology in all other fields (e.g., aerospace, medical devices).

A JDA is a powerful tool for accelerating your R&D, but it must be structured with extreme care. A clear and forward-looking IP clause is essential to ensure that your collaboration creates value for both parties without compromising the core intellectual property that is the foundation of your business.

Disclaimer: This post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Reading or relying on this content does not create an attorney–client relationship. Every startup’s situation is unique, and you should consult qualified legal or tax professionals before making decisions that may affect your business.

‍